The Difference Between REITs and Real Estate Funds & Syndications
Common question is what is a
real estate investment trust or
a REIT? And how does it differ
exactly from a real estate fund
or a real estate syndication?
Let's talk about those
differences.
Let's start talking about REITs.
Real estate investment trusts.
So what exactly are they? And
how do they work? Well, a real
estate investment trust is a
fund of sorts, it is a kind of
real estate fund, what it is as
it accumulates real estate, and
it pays out based on the income
of that real estate. So all
REITs are required to pay out
90% of their income, that's
derived from rents as dividends
to their investors. Now, a REIT
really is it's a sub
classification of the tax code.
It's not a different kind of
security, as far as the SEC is
concerned, what that means is
there are REITs that are
structured as Regulation D
offerings, there are REITs that
are structured as Regulation A
offerings, and there are REITs,
that are public that have,
they've gone public. And they do
that they meet the minimum
requirements, which primarily is
a certain amount of ownership
needs to be in people other than
those managing, and that they
pay out that 90% of their
income. And that 75% or more of
their holdings is in real estate
specifically, not necessarily
not not bonds or anything like
that, but in the real estate
itself, and that they also have
more than 100 investors that are
not part of the management team
itself. That's the basic
structure of a REIT. The
benefits of a read are that they
are very liquid, especially a
public REIT, public REITs, you
can trade on the stock market,
you can log into your brokerage
account and make a trade and
then sell it the very next hour.
So they're very, very liquid.
Whereas with a real estate fund,
the private fund, it may be less
liquid. Now, private REITs are
also going to be less liquid,
but they're going to have
specific mechanisms in place in
order to get people make it
easier to liquefy their
positions, so they can sell it
at regular intervals. When a
REIT is put together, what is
oftentimes needs to happen is
that figuring out the greatest
challenge of net asset value.
Now net asset value only comes
into play as it relates to
private REITs. So private REITs
have to figure out net asset
value on a regular basis. Most
of the ones that I know and have
talked to and follow and have
consulted with those breeds,
they that are private, they do
it on a monthly basis. Now
monthly is a lot of time, it's a
lot of work in order to adjust
your net asset value. But that's
their regular schedule. Public
REITs. However, doesn't matter.
The net asset value is computed
by itself just naturally by
being on the public market. It's
how the public perceives the net
asset value and how it changes
stock price. So there you might
get valuations of you know, 30
$30 based on income or something
like that, but basically, the
bottom line is that that net
asset value is very critical for
private REITs and for public
REITs not a factor at all,
necessarily not a factor as it
relates at least as it relates
to share price because the share
price is determined by the
market itself. So let's go
through the main takeaways and
key points of REITs and real
estate funds. Number one REITs
are companies that buy and
manage property and generate
income from rents primarily,
they're not in the business of
selling bit properties for their
own sake or counting on
appreciation. They distribute
90% of their profits as
dividends to shareholders and
their main benefit is this
massive amount of liquidity.
Number two real estate funds and
syndications they gather funds
from multiple investors for
buying, managing, developing
selling properties. Generally
they have less liquidity, larger
minimum investment, but they
offer a much wider range of
options of things that you can
do. This is where the mat the
majority of our clients are. We
have a very small number of
REITs that we help and then we
generally Help you're all the
way from your very, very large
private equity funds, all the
way down to first time,
syndicators. Number three
investment in real estate funds.
It offers those benefits of
diversification and true
professional management but it's
subject to that market.
volatility. Generally these are
smaller, so they have a little
bit less holdings than a REIT,
which can oftentimes be quite
large. As property values
decline high fees lock in
periods, they also track
slightly different than then
reads on value. Number four
REITs. In real estate funds have
different tax implications.
REITs dividends are subject to
income tax, whereas real estate
funds and syndications in
general are much more likely to
target going being taxed at the
capital gains rate. Number five,
as a syndicator, or a real
estate fund manager yourself,
your job is to really consider
what's in it for your investors.
And what are you putting this
together for? What is your
founders investment theory, use
that in determining whether
going down the road and to the
expense and complication of
putting together a huge business
like a read, make sense? A lot
of my players very, very, very
large investors who have assets
under management of well over a
billion dollars are not REITs
and will never be REITs and do
not want to play that game. They
don't even put together funds.
They put together just straight
syndications. So your success is
not tied to well whether you are
a publicly traded REIT or not.
It's put to your success is tied
with doing the kinds of deals
and the kinds of funds that you
want to do and working with the
investors that you want to work
with. My name is Tilden
Moschetti. I am a real estate
syndication attorney with the
Moschetti Syndication Law Group.
I hope this video helped explain
that difference between REITs
and private equity funds and
syndications. If we can help you
on your journey, whether it's to
become a read or a private
equity fund or a syndicator
yourself, give us a call. We can
help you stay compliant with
Regulation D Rule 506b and 506c
and also offering the exit
expert guidance to make sure
that you get on the path that
you're going and get to the goal
that you want to get to