Real Estate Cycles & Macroeconomics: Understanding Market Trends in Syndication
Tilden Moschetti: Real estate
markets don't exist in a vacuum,
and this is critically important
when you're putting together a
syndication or a fund to make
sure that you can provide your
investors the kind of returns
that you've told them all along,
that you can get them. My name
is Tilden Moschetti, and in this
video, we're going to go through
those macro market tracking
trends to keep an eye on to make
sure that you are successful and
can deliver.
When it comes to tracking the
macro market, what we're talking
about is those big picture
things the entire United States,
what's going on now, really
here, what we're looking at is,
what phase of the real estate
cycle are we in? Are we growing?
Are we shrinking? Where is the
market going? So we can
anticipate that the data sources
we use are going to come from
things like the Bureau of Labor
Statistics and what the Fed is
doing with interest rates,
things like that. Those are the
tools that we will apply to
making sure that we do that. And
here we're going to talk now
specifically about what those
different phases of the real
estate cycle are how you can
identify what phase we're in.
The first phase of the real
estate cycle is expansion. This
is when things are looking good.
Everything is going on right on
the macro scale, what we're
looking for is there's a robust
GDP growth. GDP is massive. It's
going high. We look at major
levels of employment are
increasing, more people are
going back to work, so not
unemployment. Employment levels
are increasing, and this also
leads to more more consumer
spending. So we start to see
consumer spending go up, up up
as well, interest rates may
begin to slightly tighten as we
do this, in order to curb that
inflation from coming along. And
then overall, business and
consumer confidences are super
high. On the Real Estate
specific side, what we're
looking for is a major demand.
So there's a lot of demand on
rents. So vacancies are
extremely low, specifically. And
what you're interested in is in
the property type that you're
looking at, the asset type,
whether it's multi family,
whether it's industrial, whether
it's retail, whatever it is, we
want to see that that vacancy
factor be lower than, say,
normal times. We also want to
see new new building happening.
We want to see an acceleration
of development with along with
that declining vacancy, we want
to see rent growth go up. Rent
growth is the number one
predictor of success in a
syndication that rent growth
gives you the appreciation that
you can pay back to your
investors, and overall, your
developers are optimistic.
Everybody's looking to build in.
The general feeling in the air
is very high, and that is the
expansion phase. The next part
of the real estate cycle is what
we call the peak or over
saturation. Once we've reached a
certain point, economic growth
starts to hit a peak, and then
inflation starts taking off
massively, right? So we've hit
the absolute peak of where we're
at, inflation is going up, and
as a result of that inflation
going up, central banks start to
restrict the money policy. They
turn the volume down on on it.
So we will see interest rates
rise in those buybacks massively
decrease in what the and what
the Fed is doing. So we also
start to see that sectors are
getting overheated. So we start
to see, you know this, it's kind
of turbulent times in pricing,
or in rents or something like
that. In the real estate
specific side, we start to see
the the demand and supply
reached kind of an equal
equilibrium. We're not seeing
any any decreases in the amount
of vacancy, but we're not seeing
any massive increases. It's just
started to level off rents.
Growth is not happening, really
at all. It's kind of plateaued.
Rents being where they're at.
New Construction is probably
still continuing with developers
who came in late, so they're
still developing, and they're
still trying to get it done. So
relying on new development is
not really the best indicator.
Now, as vacancy starts to
stabilize over, building starts
to begin, and that's what leads
to this oversupply, because
we've got this backlog of
developers, right? We've got 12
to 18 months these developers
have been working on it. If they
got in late cycle, you know? And
there's six months of still, of
good times, and now we're it's
starting to be over there in
that oversupply period. So we
see then rents start to come
down. And as rents start to come
down, that's what transitions us
into the next cycle. The third
part of the real estate cycle is
the slowdown or the recession.
This is after that oversupply.
And so right now, we've got way
too much stuff being built.
There's not the demand for it.
And so what does a property
owner want to do? They need to
decrease rents to improve their
vacancy. It's better to have a
property with collecting less
rent than collecting no rent at
all. Right, so that's what, what
they're going to be doing on the
macro scale and the country sky
scale, economic activity is
slowing down. GDP starts to turn
negative. We see that inverse of
the yield curve happening. So
employment levels are starting
to decline as cons and consumer
spending starts to go down and
and consumer confidence starts
to go down. At this point,
central banks are probably
thinking about, well, we need to
at least stop raising interest
rates and probably turn the
volume back up just a little bit
so we might see a little bit of
a cut of interest rates to ease
off on the recession. But
really, we're trying, and really
there they're trying to prop up,
not inflation, because inflation
shouldn't be the problem at this
point. What? What is the problem
is that employment, that's their
other part of their mandate to
ensure employment. So as
employment starts to go down,
they're probably starting to
maybe cut interest rates in
order to keep employment higher.
We also see a decline in
business activity going on on
the real estate side, we see
that massive decrease in real
estate usage, higher vacancy,
lower rents. There is a negative
rent growth most of the time, or
at least stagnant right? At
least rent growth. Rent isn't
growing and staying the same.
Construction just basically
slows. And you may see some
developers just freeze all their
development activity entirely.
Property values are starting to
decrease and soften. The selling
time of property starts to get
longer and longer and longer and
generally cap rates start going
up. The fourth part of the cycle
that leads us into is the
trough. So that's when that
recovery starts beginning. So
once we've bottomed out, once
we've hit that economic activity
at its lowest point, that's when
this cycle starts taking place.
We've got super high
unemployment, but layoffs start
to slow, which signals, well,
maybe a recovery is coming.
Central banks are probably
freaking out right now, and
their main they're starting to
shift that interest rate lower
to try and keep the try and get
the employment levels back up as
well. Consumer confidence is
basically pretty low. It's near
the bottom, but maybe it's
starting to improve just
slightly. On the real estate
side, we see property values are
at their lowest level. That
they're going to be high, high
vacancies are there, but we
start to see some absorption
happening. So we've we might
start to see some of the the
vacancy rate go down just
subtly. This will eventually
lead into the the period where
we're cut, where we're
expanding, so we might just see
that little bit of a bottom
starting to come up. Now,
actually, construction is
minimal at this point, but what
what developers are doing is
they're acquiring land or
projects to develop. This is
generally when they try to come
in and start working on their
entitlements, because they know
what's coming in that next
cycle, and they want to prime it
so that they can do it then be
done by the right before that
peak. My name is Tilden
Moschetti. I am a syndication
attorney for the Moschetti
syndication Law Group. We went
through these, these key parts
of the real estate cycle today,
mostly to help you with
identifying how where you're at
in the cycle, so that you can
provide for your investors, you
can provide for yourself, make
sure that your funds and
syndications are successful. If
we can help you with the legal
compliance side or just helping
you with putting your deals
together in the structuring side
as well, give us a call, and
let's see how my firm can help
you. You.
Unknown: The country for.