Mastering Lease Analysis: A Guide for Real Estate Syndications
One very important skill that
every syndicator, who does real
estate, every fund manager who
does real estate they need to
understand, even if they
delegate this out is how to do a
lease analysis. In real estate,
the investment real estate
world, the very bottom layer,
what drives everything is the
lease, it all comes back to the
lease, all the properties come
back to the lease, right. That's
how it generates the money. If
it wasn't for leases, it
wouldn't be realistic, it could
be something else and wouldn't
be an underlying investment real
estate property. So it could be
still related to real estate,
but it wouldn't be a real estate
investment thing that you're
doing. So in this video comes
from, again the past, but what
it does is it talks specifically
about how we do lease analysis,
I put this video together for
the very top of the industry. So
the very top real estate
brokers, real estate developers,
people who really understood
leases and understood it in
context of well how a property
is done. But when it comes to
actually running a property from
an asset management point of
view, not a property manager,
but from the asset level, we
need to understand the whole
lease structure and where each
lease lies within it. So I know
you're going to find this video
useful if you do real estate at
all. This is where we talk about
how to actually figure out what
that absolutely fundamental
building block, the lease is,
and all the terms of everything
that move it change our value of
the proper underlying property,
or the which, of course,
underlies the entire portfolio,
whether you have one property,
or 1000 properties, it doesn't
matter, one door or 1000 doors,
it all comes back down to the
lease.
We are going to dive deep into
lease analysis also known as a
lease abstracting Now the
purpose of abstracting your
leases, so that you don't have
to dig through the leases in
order to know what the next step
is. So or when you have a tenant
who's asking, can they do this
or if they need that, it's all
there in your lease abstract, it
makes your life much much
simpler and easier to manage the
property. Even if you are not
acting as the property manager,
it helps you as the asset
manager under the command
structure to be able to
understand where you're at in
your leases, it will make it
easier for you to communicate to
your investors. And ultimately,
when it's time to sell the
property, it will make
developing that rent roll much
much easier because we actually
do the rent roll as part of this
process as well. So let's start
at the beginning. I'm going to
list out here pretty much all
the things that I like to see in
a lease abstract, and then I'll
give you kind of some hints
along the way as to where about
you'll find them. So first is
the date of the lease. This is
normally at the very beginning
of the lease itself. I like to
know this because I like to know
when this was entered into it
helps me sort through when
everything happened in time
because as time goes on, you're
going to be getting amendments
made as tenants renew, and so it
helps to have that date of the
lease or the date of amendment
at the top. I like to know when
the term commenced, or is going
to commence. Want to know that
so that it's very easy to see
what that date is. I want to see
when rent started. Sometimes
these are on the same date, but
it's not always the same date.
So I like to know sometimes the
term commences there's a period
of rent abatement, and then rent
starts two months later, for
example, sometimes it is that
the term commences when the
rental period starts. I've
looked like to know what what
period that is. And then when is
this lease expiring? I want to
know that so I can keep that in
mind and it's put make it a part
of my rent roll and so that I
know when that lease is no
longer going to be useful. I
should also mention at the top
here, I kind of like to put the
tenant name just so I know who
we're talking about and In the
unit number it makes it easier.
Alright, so now what I like to
do is I like to, when I'm
writing these out, everything
below this part, so everything
after this, I like to do two
columns, sometimes more, but
certainly two columns. And what
I want to know is I want to
know, what paragraphs what
paragraph number, I find it in.
So it's very, very simple for me
to see. And then I have the
category. And then there is the
answer. We fill in the blank. So
what I, for example, I want to
know what the definition of
premises is. And this is
probably this maybe something
like the premises itself is the,
the unit number or the premises
is, you know, the whole building
or whatever it is. I like to
have that definition. Normally,
this is in paragraphs one or two
or something like that. But
here, let's just, let's just say
in here, we found it in
paragraph 1.1. And then I would
put the specific answer. Now
here, I probably am going to use
some shorthand, I would do
something like unit to a one of
building something like that. So
premises, I want to know, what
is the permitted use? Now, this
is very, I mean, you're
certainly gonna have this as it
relates to a retail building an
office building, you may or may
not, there may be some
restrictions on use. Certainly,
if it was medical, you probably
would include that. If it's not
medically, you probably
wouldn't. And then, but I like
to put in the permitted use now
in an apartment building, you
probably don't have it, I've may
still put it there. Leave it
there, just so that I know that
if something comes up, and
there's a specific restriction
that's been put in there kind of
on the way they use the
property, I may put it there.
Like it's like they're going to
be using it as an air b&b or
something like that. I may want
to know. And I may want to know
whether I gave them permission,
I want to know what the square
footage is. In that lease, how
it's defined. I want to know
what what parking looks like,
have there been allocated one
space two space, three spaces?
How's it done? Where are those
parking spaces? It's all in the
lease. And again, as we're going
through these, we're putting in
where, what paragraph number?
And we're filling in what the
answer is on. On for each
category. I want to know the
term in months. How long is this
lease gonna last? I want to know
what how much have they paid
in their security deposit. And
certainly as things change,
sometimes you get an increase in
security deposit. And so let's
say this was an amendment it may
say something like they gave me
$5,000. On June 120, whatever
the year is, and then the
following year, they added $500
on May 31, and whatever that
year is I may want to do that.
So that way I know okay, I've
got a running tally of what that
security deposit is. So it's
always there. I never have to
look at a lease and it's all
done properly. Then I've got my
renewal options.
The next section I break down is
so these are sort of like the
main or the main sort of basic
categories that probably fit
into your rent roll along with
part of the next section. And
what this does is this sort of
sets up some of the more
important things are not more
important than the things that
are referenced more frequently.
The next part I will put is I'll
build a table. And what I'll do
is I'll put build a table that
has a rental periods so that I
know what time period we're
talking about how much we're
talking, and rent per month.
What this translates into rent
per year. And then I want to
know also, not in my apartment
buildings necessarily, but maybe
you might as well put it is
what's my cost per square foot,
by either month or year
depending on what what, what's
normal for your industry. So in
California, it's month, most of
the other country, it's a year.
But whatever you were most used
to seeing it is and what the
escalations are
now notice right now, I'm not
talking about pass throughs at
all, I'm all I'm talking about
is just rent. So in here, I may
say, Let's do an example. So I
may say, June 120, through May
31.
This is a table remember. And so
my rent dollar amount is say,
oh, let's do what we'll do $1
Oh, we'll do just for keeping
math easy. We'll say it's $1 a
month. $1 a square foot month,
which means that's 12. And let's
say it's 1000 square feet. So
that's, that's $12,000 per year,
$1,000 per month. And then my
escalations are gonna take place
that next year, right most of
the time, that's when they
happen. And so it'll be
starting. Now, obviously, you'll
put this in a spreadsheet. And
that'll be a lot easier way to
do it. And you can automate the
calculation of all those things
as well. And so I would put now
say there is a 5%. That's an
awfully high rent bump, we'll
make it a 3%. And so that would
suddenly bring my dollars per
month to $1,030. My rent per
month, is, let's see, if I can
do this quickly in my head
$12,360 per year, my cost per
square foot is now $1.03. And
then next year, it's going to be
another 3% rent, for example. So
that's the way I would do this
next section on what the rents
are. Now, I would still put the
over here, I would still put
what paragraph number in the
lease that's found, because it's
gonna make your life much much
simpler when you need it. So
basically, we're building out a
cheat sheet so that we can
quickly find whatever we need to
do in the lease. Because if you
have a tenant in front of you,
and they're saying, Well, why is
it this you can just simply say,
okay, look, paragraph three in
your lease says this. Underneath
here, I like to just put a
section for percentage rent, if
as if it is a retail space. And
then I want to also now I want
to code to kind of some of the
other money kinds of things so
I've got percentage rent. I
would put a section on what
tenant improvements rent
abatement Construction was a
made available so I'd put a
space for that and again always
putting the paragraphs so I can
find it then I would put a
section for landlord repairs now
you're not looking for this to
be comprehensive This is a table
of contents or an index or
whatever to make it simple for
you so I would put you know
landlord repairs replace carpet
I don't know what it is whatever
it is replace carpet change
fixtures whatever is normal for
what you're doing and then
tenant repairs so this landlord
repairs can be in the first part
and then tenant repairs would be
you know, tenant is going to be
install UPS
installing new bathroom. Now,
this is for, I tend to use this
for these specific things at the
outset of the lease, you could
also use this same kind of
section to say that the tenant
is or the landlord repairs and I
probably wouldn't would still
note it here. So a common thing
in a retail space is the
landlord's responsible for
windows, doors, roof structure.
And here, everything else, you
know, the tenant takes care. And
when there's specific different
sections, I'll probably put
paragraph five. And then here,
put paragraph seven, or wherever
it is, again, so it's easy for
me to find. Now the next thing
is I do build out a table of
operating expenses and pastures.
So here we've got we still are
doing our paragraphs, right so
so I've got my paragraph labels
going down. And now I've got my
operating expenses, rebuilding
another table and so here I'm
looking for the normal ones. And
if you have things that are in
addition, great then add those
two
real estate taxes, cams
insurance now I make this a
personally I make this a
checkbox to make it's kind of
simple. So I put in like
landlord pays.
tenant pays
tenant pays, pro rata. And then
if there are any expense stops
and caps.
So then filling this out, you
know for utilities, it's
something like tenant pays their
pro rata share. Or let's do a
little bit differently. tenant
pays tenants paying for all
their utilities, it's under
their name. Real estate taxes is
the tenants paying their pro
rata share. Cams is that tenants
paying pro rata share insurance
is paying their pro rata share.
But let's say there is a cap on
property taxes of no more than
3% per year. Something just to
give me an idea about whatever
it says. So, then I like to get
into more of the legal type of
questions that are here. So I
want the section for
destruction. I want the section
for CO tenancy do they have the
right to do a or to have to
share that space condemnation
rights now these are probably
things you're not going to need
much but it also helps when
you're filling out your estoppel
certificate. So that's another
reason expansion rights these
does happen so do they have the
right to occupy another space
becomes available
Alright, and now we get into
kind of the things that that are
referenced the most so you'll
see what we've done is we've
kind of referenced the things
that are very frequent over here
you know, those you're
referencing all the time now
rents you are referencing to
some extent that this is getting
pulled over into your renderable
so you're probably not
referencing that much you're
referencing cams this section
you're not going to reference
quite as much here are the
things that certainly come up
and when you need them you want
to know right where they are in
the lease rather than having to
dig for it. So this section is
May the
May the tenant assign without
landlord consent in paragraph
six still going here what I do
is I normally put either a yes
or no and then if it's a yes I
want to explain
next question is does tenant
have exclusivity? If Do they
have any exclusivity rights? And
I do again do yes No. And
explain this these things now
come up much less after this.
These things I certainly want to
know about. But here's these are
certain things that will make it
easy just to have them all there
for when they come up. So is the
lease subordinate? To mortgage?
In other words, do they need to
sign an snda? answer is probably
yes, but I want to know it and I
want to know what paragraph so
that I've had I've dealt with
situations where tenants have
refused to sign NDAs and and
it's very frustrating and it
makes it much easier if you can
quickly tell them right where in
the lease they have to sign it I
want to know do they have to
sign an estoppel and I will know
where that happens a lot too.
And then the others are Is there
a purchase option I do do they
have a right of first refusal
Do they have any early
terminations
and anything else any other
thing notes I want to put here
and then last I like to close it
out sort of the same way the
lease is typically written I
want to know is there at least
guarantee
I want to know if there are any
lease amendments. And so you see
this is an evolving document. I
want to know who's signed it.
And when one thing I should also
mention is under renewal options
have so. So you may have options
for the, for the renewals, I put
those up here. So I put option
period one. And I put your six
through 10, whatever it is, and
then I'll put whatever the
information is there. So that
way, then I've got, I know at a
glance that there are renewal
options that are out there. And
it makes it pretty
straightforward. So this purpose
of lease abstracting isn't just
an exercise in in, in generating
paperwork, this is to make your
job easier. And it's really to
get your stuff together so that
when your investors have a
question, or when anybody has a
question your property manager,
if that's you, or if you have
one, need something specific to
provide a tenant, or so you can
just have a baseline so you can
look at what you're doing across
your center in one straight
place. And really kind of move
everybody to getting the same
similar kind of lease, this is
the way to do it. So we do that
with lease abstracting. And this
is part of lease analysis. My
very first mentor taught me a
very, very important thing. He
said, when there's ever a
question, it comes to the lease,
go to the lease, read the lease,
it always is the lease. I heard
that in law school. I heard that
in understanding real estate
when I was studying. For my CCIE
am, my original mentor taught me
that always, always always, it's
the lease that controls the
entire thing. And that's why we
do lease analysis. That's why we
need to understand those basic
building blocks. Also, as you
saw in this video, it has
pointers to where all those
things are in the lease. So if
you ever need to understand it,
it's all right there for you. My
name is Tilden Moschetti. I am a
syndication attorney for the
Moschetti syndication Law Group.
Before I was a syndication
attorney 10 years ago, before
this, I was a real estate
litigator. What does that mean?
Most of the time I was referring
to the lease. I didn't do
evictions or that sort of thing.
But when it comes to it, my my
issues tended to revolve around
doing cases where property was
at stake, where property was the
main issue, not eviction, not
tenancy, not things like that.
So most of the time it was fight
over the property and ownerships
of the property. And when that
happens, what's very important
is value. And when is value and
what's the key building block in
value for any kind of commercial
real estate? It's the lease. And
so that's why we did this video.
If I can help you do your own
syndication investment fund get
you started doing your own 506 B
or 506 C syndication, whether
it's real estate or totally
unrelated to real estate. I
would be happy to talk with you