Fiduciary Duties in Syndications: Key Principles
Tilden Moschetti: What does it
mean to have a fiduciary duty
for a syndicator or a fund
manager? It is a principal thing
that should be ingrained in your
blood. It should be a visceral
feeling that you have, that
you've got this fiduciary duty
and you treat your investors
appropriately. Now, what do I
mean by this, let's talk about
it in this video.
A fiduciary duty is simply
putting your the best interest
of your investors before your
own. Now that sounds very easy
and lofty, but what does it
exactly mean? There are five
principles of fiduciary duty,
the duty of loyalty, duty of
care, duty of confidentiality,
and the duty of impartiality,
and we'll go through each of
those. But basically, think
about your fiduciary duty this
way. This is the way I like to
think of it, your investors are
giving you an enormous amount of
money. They're giving you 50,000
100,000
sometimes over a million dollars
of their money. That's an
enormous amount of trust that
they're placing with you. And we
have to take that extremely
seriously, and that's why, when
I say you have got to feel it,
you've got to really feel that
level of trust. Because, man,
there are putting a lot of trust
in you, and you've better earn
it. So it's not and by earn it,
I don't mean you have to hit the
targets or else. I mean you just
got to do your very best for
them every single time and in
every decision you make, the
duty of loyalty is the first
main principle. It's the duty to
act in the best interest of the
investors, avoid conflicts of
interest and prioritizing the
goals of the syndication over
your personal gain. So by this,
what we really mean is, I like
to think of it as avoiding
conflicts of interest. Now,
there may be, there always are
conflicts of interest in a
syndication, but like taking a
kickback or things like that, is
never in your best interest of
your investors. It's okay to do
that, but I would disclose it up
front, like, for example, I'm
going to be paid, you know, by
10% of the development fee by
the developer who's going to be
hiring us for this, something
like that. Whatever it is, it's
got to be disclosed and made
super, super clear, because we
don't want even the appearance
of a breach of the duty of
loyalty. If you're not going to
be 100% you got to just tell
them, tell them that you're
doing it.
So that's the number one thing,
is, have this duty of loyalty.
The second key principle of
fiduciary duties is the duty of
care. Remember, they've given
you all this money. How would
you want your money manager or
your syndicator you've given all
of your money to to treat it?
You would want them to do every
single thing that they can in
order to take good care, nurture
it, Shepherd it, steward it,
whatever words you like, in
order to make sure that you get
what kind of return is possible.
So really it's making all those
good decisions, being thorough,
conducting good due diligence,
really just working hard and
being truly, truly professional
about every single element of
your syndication or your fund.
The third key principle of
fiduciary duty is a duty of
disclosure. It's telling your
investors about everything that
they need to know. If it's
material, they need to know it.
They don't need to know that the
third blade of grass finally
came, grew in. They don't need
to know that level of detail,
but they may need to know that,
hey, we had some vandalism that
took place on the property, and
it wiped out a whole section of
our thing. And now we've got to
go find a new gardener in order
to do this. Whatever that is
right, that's relevant, that's
material, disclosing that,
especially disclosing before
they invest right? So anything
that they might be interested
in, conflicts of interest,
especially that you're going to
be getting kickbacks, or how you
get paid, how what your
interests are in the property,
those sort of things should be
disclosed. Anything that could
change a potential investor from
a yes to a no, they need to know
about very, very clear, that is
the duty of disclosure, the
fourth principle of fiduciary
duty. And I take this one very
seriously, and I'm probably
different than a lot of other
syndication attorneys as it
comes to this, is the duty of
confidentiality. Your investors
are trusting you with a lot of
money. I've done quite.
Few syndications for myself. I
continue to do syndications, and
I have investors in my roster
who have invested in my
projects, who are well known
people, right? So they are
people who are sometimes
household names or people that
you probably have heard of as
well. It is paramount that their
their confidentiality is
maintained. They don't want
everybody knowing about well, we
this person invested in this
thing and this person invested
in that thing. It's not relevant
to everybody else. It's relevant
to them, to their investment
decision, maybe to their wealth
advisor, whatever. But it's not
relevant to every other
investor. I make sure that we
have this discussion when I'm
putting together a PPM and an
operating agreement, because I
think that duty of
confidentiality is very
important. I know as a as an
investor myself, I don't want my
how the amount of money that
I've invested, or even the fact
that I've invested in a certain
project, to be known unless I
really make it clear that I want
it to be known, which is
probably never the case. So that
duty of confidentiality is one
of the key
fiduciary duties, and it should
be a part of your syndication or
fund as well. The last fiduciary
duty is the duty of
impartiality. Now this actually
comes up a fair amount so, and
where it comes up most often is
in redemptions. So let's say
you've got a fund that has a
portfolio of $20 million and you
have decided, okay, we're going
to make available $2 million
that for redemption so people
can get their cash out. Because
we're shrink, starting to bring
down the portfolio size.
You have a choice to make, and
how you can apportion that, that
redemption availability, out to
your investors? You could just
go to your favorite investor,
but would that be fair to all
the other investors? No, it
would not be. We have to be very
careful to not favor other
investors, and not by dollar
amount either. So it doesn't
matter whether the you have
somebody who invested $50,000
and a million dollars, you need
to treat them fairly, but you
treat them fairly in proportion
to each other. So you may allow
a redemption for both those
investors, but it has to be in
proportion to their investment.
So that way it is truly
important, impartial on $1 for
dollar basis, not on a per
investor per investor basis.
That's the way I think is most
fair. It's the way nearly
everybody wants to put it in
their syndication documents as
well.
We have to favor things very,
very fairly and really think
about what is the fairest way to
do it for all of those investors
at the same time. My name is
Tilden Moschetti. I'm a
syndication attorney with the
Moschetti syndication Law Group.
We help invest syndicators and
fund managers just like
yourself, in order to be
compliant with all of the SEC
rules and state rules, and at
the same time, we help you
through this kind of decision
making on how to be the best
fiduciary you can be, because it
not isn't not just good business
and lawful, but it also makes
your investors happy, Which
means they stay with you and
keep investing with you. So it's
a good thing to be doing if we
can help you with your
syndication or your fun, give us
a call, set up an appointment,
and let's talk about what you're
working on.
You.