Behavioral Finance for Syndicators and Fund Managers Part 2: Cognitive Biases - Conservatism...
What are some of the cognitive
biases that we have, under this
idea of behavioral finance, that
impact us as syndicators as fund
managers, this is part two of a
six part series that we're doing
on behavioral finance. So this
part is broken into, there's
going to be three parts total.
So the first part was just that
first video to go through what
is behavioral finance? The
second part, which is going to
be comprised of three videos
itself is going to go through
what are the cognitive biases
that we have? And then that
third part is going to go over?
What are the remaining? What are
the remaining six different
kinds of emotional biases we
have, I know you're going to
like this series, this is part
two, we're going to start
talking about cognitive biases.
So we're talking about cognitive
biases. So these are biases that
are faulty decision making. So
it's a fault in our error in our
in our ability to make a
decision properly, it's an error
in the logic itself. So it's not
in anything that's emotional.
It's part of the rational part
of us that we're trying to use
to apply to make rational
decisions. But an error occurs.
So there's, there are total of
nine different of these biases.
And we're going to go through
three of them. So let's go to
the whiteboard. So these are
these are the nine different
biases that there are in the
cognitive space. So today, we're
going to talk just about these
first three. So we're going to
talk about conservatism. We're
going to talk about
confirmation, and we're going to
talk about control. We'll talk
about the other ones in the next
videos. So what is conservatism?
So conservatism is a cognitive
bias. It says that when we get
new info, that we ignore it.
So you get new info, and then we
choose we choose or for whatever
reason, it's ignored. Now, if
you know what the Bayesian
framework is, so Bayesian
framework is saying, well,
there's this many people in
group A, and that may end of
that. There are also this many
in Group B. And we know that
there's this likelihood of these
events occurring, it's actually
a very formal process where we
can actually figure out what any
statistic is based on the sets
that we're using. So it's, as a
new element gets added to that
as a new pool of resources as a
new statistic or something new,
something that should shift our
analysis. We're discord we're
discounting it. So it would be
to not pay attention and not
factor it in. So it's saying
that we're going to maintain
original analysis. And that's
what conservatism is. So it's
taking that idea of, okay, new
information is coming in. But
we've already made that
decision. So you're you're
discounting information only
because you've got, you've
already got the existing the one
in now similar, but different is
this idea of confirmation bias.
And you might have heard of what
confirmation bias. This is
certainly one that I think a lot
of syndicators have, I know that
it's something I have to watch
out for myself. So it's almost
all of us have it. It's very,
very prevalent. I certainly am
very guilty of it as well. But
it is part of something that I
actively try to stomp out and
myself because it is so readily
present there. It's just such a
natural tendency to do. So
confirmation bias says okay,
I've identified this thing as
this thing. Right. And when new
information comes in
let's actually go We'll use it.
So
as new information comes in,
we're getting this this line
here that saying we've got a
coming in. Okay, that's good.
Yep. See a, put that down on our
list. As another reason why.
Okay, we got this second one.
It's another vote for a. Let's
put that down as another reason
why, Oh, we got this thing in as
B. All right, get rid of that.
All right. Okay, another piece
of information is coming in.
It's a great, let's keep it
another piece of information
coming in. This one's B. It
that's an All right. So it's a.
So it's the confirming, right?
So it's taking in all the
information. Unlike
conservatism, it's taking in
that new information. But it's
only accepting that information
that confirms what our original
analysis set. So very, very
prevalent out there, right? I
mean, it's certainly something
that's there, it's really hard
to change our minds. I'm sure
that you see it in, not just in,
in an analysis of a building or
analysis of a, of an
opportunity, or some sort of
offer you're putting together,
but you certainly see it in
politics, or you certainly see
it and mediary certainly see it
and all sorts of things, that we
take this idea, and it doesn't
matter what other ideas are
coming in, we automatically
gravitate naturally, to confirm
our original idea. We don't want
to change, we all have it. When
it comes to putting doing a
syndication or a fund and an
asset management though, new
information is coming in all the
time. And Facts are facts,
right. So I can't ignore the
facts. But I do, right, because
if it's if even if it's, if it's
contradictory to what I already
want it to be, I'm gonna ignore
it nine times out of 10 If I'm
not careful. So that's the
confirmation bias. It's really,
really dangerous, and so
prevalent out there. So think
about that. And then I started
thinking for in your, in your
own life, where do you have
these issues about confirmation
bias? I bet you have them. This
third topic of a cognitive bias
is what we call control bias. So
this is the the the thought
that, that we have more control
over something than we actually
do. So what this is, is, say
you've got let's use real estate
for an example. And say, in this
town, you've got, you know,
you've got 1-234-567-8910 Let's
actually delete this one, and
move it over there. All right,
you've got it you've got 10
minutes you've got about nine
buildings. Here we go. Now 1010
domains, right. Now a new one
pops up this circle, we can see
which one it is. Let's do one
pops up. Well, you've got 10
other buildings, and they're all
surrounding this building. And
so surely you have you, you
know, the city council. Right,
you know, everybody there, you
know, all the tenants in the
area that are going to come you
it's the control is the the
misbelief that you have that you
have control over just this
area. That anything that happens
within here, you have some sort
of leg up on the competition.
Now what this does is it over
develops a concentration in this
area. So the control bias says
okay, it's this. So a lot of
people will will ask me what
what I syndicate when I
syndicate a pro or D or I do I
do a syndication? I'd make it
pretty clear. I don't actually
have an asset type that I stick
due, it's not part of my fit.
It's just not what I do I care
about good deals, right? I have
a whole laundry list of what
kind of fits in my in my fit and
a very clear explanation of it.
But one thing that is not there
is asset type. asset type is not
there. Why? Because of this
illusion of control. So, that's
one where I've left this idea of
control. And I use that as an
example. Because a lot of people
think the other way, they think,
Well, I am a master of mostly
what we see as multifamily. I've
been doing multifamily forever,
it's got I've got, you know, $15
trillion, under, under my
management, I know everything
about it, I've got control over
this, I'm gonna keep doing this,
I am the best there is at this.
And you may be you may have
absolutely some special skill.
But it also is an illusion of
control. Because it also may,
you may make assumptions that on
your risk profile because of
these other 10 buildings that
are here about what's going to
happen here. Because of you have
this belief that you have
control over.
So those are the first three of
our cognitive biases. So
conservatism, confirmation and
control. In the next video,
we're going to go through the
next three, which is
representativeness, framing, and
hindsight. So those are the next
three cognitive biases that
we're going to go through. My
name is Tilden Moschetti. I am a
syndication attorney with the
Moschetti Syndication Law Group.
coming to you with this six part
series also, because I'm an
active syndicator and fund
manager just like you. So I am a
lawyer, I put, we help people
put together 506(b) and 506(c)
offers, but I also put it
together my own deals. And so
with these behavioral
biases that we have, they're
certainly present in me as well.
And I thought it would be useful
to make sure that we conveyed
those to you as well, because
I'm sure you'll find them
useful. And ultimately, what
we're all after as the same
thing, get better returns to our
investors, so they keep
investing with us. We can make
the most amount of money that we
can, they can make the most
amount of money. Everybody's
happy. It's a win win.