How to Evaluate a Real Estate Syndication Deal: The Four Steps to Mastering Financial Analysis
I have a four step financial
analysis workflow that I do for
every real estate syndication
that I look at. Now, having an
actual formal process is
critical. And understanding
financial analysis is the
backbone, it's the only thing
that's going to make you truly
successful in as a real estate
syndicator, or a real estate
fund manager. So I hope you find
this useful. I used to have a
training program about two or
three years ago, it was called
altitude and altitude. That's
why it's called the altitude
four step financial analysis,
this is still the same analysis
that I use today on every deal
that I look at.
So it all starts with, as we
talked about last week, it
starts with these basic facts
and assumptions. We talked about
last week, how there is a range
and how, in the very beginning
of your analysis, it starts
very, very fact based with a
little bit of assumptions based.
And then it changes though, from
there, it starts getting as time
goes on. And as we go from just
needing an A Y to getting in a
pro forma or a five year cash
flow, we start getting more and
more assumptions. And so there
are some assumptions that we
make along the whole process.
And we'll see that go on. But we
also have assumptions that are
that we determined at the very
beginning. So after we determine
what our basic facts and our
assumptions are, we then go
through and figure out what our
NOI is, and our potential value.
And I say potential value,
because there is a big
assumption there in determining
value, we're applying a cap rate
of a market cap rate, this
property hasn't been appraised,
it's just what we think it would
go for. And so there we go. So
after our, we've determined our
NOI and our potential value, let
me get this out of the way.
After we've determined our NOI
and our potential value, we then
are looking at at cash flow.
And so here again, is getting a
lot more assumption based. And
then finally, after we've
determined what the cash flow
looks like, we have performance.
So these are the four steps.
Under performance, I consider
that not only how is the
property potentially doing what
are those projections about
return, but I also look at it as
well how would it perform as a
syndication? How did those
measures line up? So performance
is really tied into not only
just the regular, what's the IRR
potential potentiality of the
property, but also those
measures on is this even a good
investment for us to look at. So
under these, each of these has
matures, a different pen color
actually I need to do this
again. Do that again.
So we're gonna do this in blue.
So now in each of these are
different what we call different
pieces of the puzzle that go
underneath them all. So under
here obviously, if we're talking
about basic facts and
assumptions, we've got facts Oh,
that's
we've got facts. We've got
assumptions
we have market data.
Under and so those are the key
things instead go into that main
step. Now under the next step,
the NOI and potential value,
here, we've got rent roll which
also feeds into income. And we
have operating expenses. Now,
that's not surprising, because
these are what comes up in our
noi calculation.
Under cash flow, we have things
like debt. We have capital
expenses. Actually, I like to
think I'm gonna call them other
expenses
we have reserves. And
interestingly, we have a we have
taxes, the taxes isn't really
something we consider very much
on. On the one we're doing a
syndication, but it is important
to know what the the after tax
cash flow is, as well, just
because you may still need it
for whatever your other purposes
are, if you have somebody who's
actually going to be buying it
for you clears, things like
that, it's useful to know it
fits in just fine on our cash
flow, because all of those same
things also feed into our
discussion of you know, all the
things that are taxed also feed
into our our discussion on
whether or not it is a good how
the performances. And so in
performance that we consider a
few other things we consider the
purchase. And the sale, we
consider the equity.
And then we consider measures.
And so these parts all go to our
four step program now, there are
at almost every level of this
again could just erase that. All
right, there are at almost every
level, actually.
There are at almost every level.
And the most important thing out
of this, that I'm trying to get
across is there are different
levers that move each of the
main functions. So there are a
series of levers that come from
noi that change our NOI and our
potential value. So these are
the NY lovers. We have our
income amounts, and that's rent
roll, things like that. And a
lot of those things start off as
facts right. So the whatever
that let the income is, is the
income or so you think but we
also have some things that just
income like whether or not we're
choosing to do pass throughs and
whether or not we'd be able to
pass through everything that
we're thinking, what we're using
for a vacancy factor what we're
using for a credit factor things
like that. So I put it as a
broad idea just to start
thinking about income is
certainly a big lever and
expenses is of Asli a big lever
and on expenses, I am
specifically not saying that it
is that it is that we can change
what we consider an operating
expenses. Because operating
expenses are a parody objective.
It's pretty standard on what we
consider an operating expense.
But what we choose to use as our
measure for it has some
assumptions built into it. There
is other income there is your
vacancy, as I said, your credit
risk
we've got your your pass
throughs. Got management and
certainly if you are doing me
Management yourself, how much
you charge for the management is
certainly a lever that you could
change the entire noi with,
which flows all the way down to
basically what your your the
return that your investors would
be getting. So there are also
coming out of this same box,
there's also levers for your
potential value, right? I'm
there, I mean, we've got our
Analy. We've got our price. And
we've got our cap rates. I mean,
we've got I mean that because
price equals noi over cap rate.
So any of those things can
adjust, obviously, what that
potential value is, out of cash
flow, there are also major
levers. And what you'll notice
here, so our first our first big
one is noi noi changes our cash
flow. So these things feed up
into themselves. So every single
one of the levers that is within
NOI is within cash flow. And
you'll see as we go on every one
of the ledger levers that's in
cash flow also has an effect on
performance. But some of the
measures in cash flow do not
have a downward effect. They're
not affecting things within and
why. So under this, we've got,
for example, debt. Whether or
not we change our change debt
has absolutely no difference on
noi, it doesn't change it one
bit. And so it is not a lever of
noi, but it sure is a lever on
the amount of cash flow. We also
have our CapEx, we've got our
asset management fees comes out
of cash flow, it's a
discretionary spend, but it's
coming out of that cash flow. So
it is a lever that can change
and it can change everything
else it changes our cash flow
and it ultimately changes the
return for investors. We've got
our how much we are going to
keep in reserves or how we're
going to build up reserves, what
assumptions we use for growth,
and what is our hold period.
Actually, let's use let's change
hold period up the level. So
these are the main main Levers
as it relates to up there we go
as it relates to cash flow. Now
performance has its own levers
obviously.
So here we've got just like we
talked about, we got our we have
our cash flow, you know, it
comes up. And because it comes
up we also have NOI is is also a
lever, we have the price we're
willing to pay and then the
projected sales price
we have sales fees. We have our
purchase and syndication fees
we have waterfalls we have hold
periods and to some extent we
have what our discount rate is.
Alright, so here is why we're
talking about this now. When
we're doing financial analysis
and ultimately underwriting
we're putting together a package
that we can show potential
investors of what we're
expecting it to how we're
expecting it to perform, by
understanding the different
levers that take place within
that process, financial analysis
and or underwriting. The more we
understand those levers the more
we can tune it to being a an
asset that will work in order
for investors to be in listed at
all, it's also important to kind
of get how it all goes together
like this. Because when you're
having those conversations, and
if you're dealing with a more
sophisticated investor, it's
much easier when you've got the
framework in your head about
what this looks like to switch
gears, switch gear, switch gear
and know what they're talking
about, and be able to get it
back to really addressing what
their question is, or if they
have a particular issue, or they
just want to know why you're
doing something, the way you're
doing it. If you have the model
in your head, it really makes
sense. And that's also why we're
talking about underwriting and
financial analysis at all in
this program. Because
theoretically, you could just
take, you know, the simple thing
off of off of a sales brochure
that you're getting then and use
that for your underwriting and
figure out okay, well, we're
going to, we're going to be
making this much money and just
kind of hope that everything
works out. But if you have all
these things in mind, you've got
now you can have real
conversations with investors
about how everything works. And
then you can also fine tune it
as it's going and it make
determinations. Maybe you've
decided, well, I don't think our
reserves is high enough. But
that how is that going to affect
everything else? Well, it's
going to if I need to increase
my reserves, that means I have
less cash flow, which means that
my ultimately the timing of get
my distributions is going to get
thrown off, which means that I
will need to let my investors
know, hey, look, the overall
return for this period isn't
going to be what we thought it
would be because we really want
to build up those reserves. So
you can be having those kinds of
conversations when you get the
model and you can make changes
on the fly. So let's go to let
me ask her those questions.
Yeah. Hello, Andrew, do you have
a question? Any questions so
far? Okay, perfect. Let me know
if you do. Alright, so let's
switch to this spreadsheet.
Alright, so here and this might
look a little familiar. This is
the CCI M. Underwriting
workbook. And I chose to start
here, rather than using what we
were using two videos ago, or
one video, goat as well, because
a lot of people will be more
familiar with these sheets, I've
actually added some stuff into
these sheets, to make it a
little bit more useful. And I
think it will give a little bit
of a basis of why of where
everything goes and how it fits
together when you see a
different model. And then you
can see how how what I'm talking
about feeds into that. So let's
go ahead and get started. And I
put these in order as well. So,
of the four steps. So let me so
this is step one. Right, this is
facts and assumptions.
So these are the assumptions
that are taking place within the
within the in their five year
analysis workbook. These and the
facts are actually more built on
the NOI page than anywhere else.
But I think it makes a little
bit more sense to separate them
out. So you'll see when we, when
we look at the the four step
tool that we use the
spreadsheet, it actually breaks
it apart into all the different
parts just to make it a little
bit more clear. And so here's
our assumptions. So Inc ordinary
income tax rate, capital gains
tax rates straight line on
recapture. Is it 25 This is
actually a 20 As of today, and
these are here because they're
part of CCI M's analysis CCI M
really focuses on invest on the
investor side and helping
investors make make good
decisions. Where as well we talk
about really is more on the
syndication side. We will go
through the taxes probably next
week, just because it is
something that you do need to
know. And why not? We're using
it in the same sheets because it
we can and it doesn't take much
more work. So here's the other
assumptions, what is the vacancy
rate going to be of your
property? How does rent
escalate? So year one, year two,
year three, year four. So right
now we have it in 3%, annual
bumps, income is other income is
escalating at 3% a year in what
we're going to be using today,
we're not going to be using
another income. Actually, no, we
will be using another other
income. So it escalates at 3% a
year, and expenses escalates at
3% a year. So and what we're
talking about actually, the
other income that we're talking
about is going to be passed
through. So it's good that those
match cap rate used in the sale,
I think those are little bit too
broad. So let's bring them a
little bit down. Let's say our
alternative is six, 6.5 and
seven, and are expensive sale, I
would say let's keep it at 6%.
That means 3% preside actually
six and a quarter. Now we'll
cover our escrow and title fees
as well. Alright, so here is
that, okay, so lease analysis
now is the next topic that we're
talking about. And I decided
rather than just go right to the
rent roll, this is a good time
to actually talk about lease
analysis. So let's go ahead and,
and put it in the right step
category that we have. So this
here, we are talking about the
NOI and potential value, step.
So let's say this is the name of
the building is 123 main. Our
first tenant is Joe's store.
They are in suite 101. And then
this is I like to have at least
at least abstracts for every
single property, I do every
tenant. And so this really has
everything that you would need.
Now it has some of the things
like right at the top, you need
to know obviously a tenant is
very important to know, right at
the top, because when you're
sorting through them, that's how
you're going to sort through
them. Alright, date of lease is
the date the lease was signed,
the term is how many how many
years it is, the rent is
whatever that rent is. The
expiration date is that. So
let's say this is June 120 21.
So a five year term, we'll deal
with rent later. And then this
would be May 31 2026. Let's say
it is a 2500 square foot
building. And we are you know
how many parking spaces they've
been allocated. I'm assuming
this is going to be just a two
unit building. And so we'll just
leave that blank term and months
60 You can put the security
deposit the renewal options you
want to fill this out completely
when you're doing your full
analysis anyway because then
you've at least got it in one
very nice easy to see area. And
this section over here where
we've got the paragraph number
now that is for exactly where it
is in the lease. So premises is
often in paragraph 1.1 permitted
use is oftentimes in paragraph
4.1. Square footage is often in
1.1. Parking is like in 1.4 I
think term is in normally it's
in to and this is just from you
know from having done this
security deposit I think isn't
Three, but I don't remember. And
renewal options is oftentimes
like in maybe 4.5 or so. And now
we've got a rental period. So
let's say we've got in year one,
so let's say it's six slash, one
slash 2021. And then it is, say,
through five slash 31, slash
2022. So dollars per month,
let's say that they are at
$5,000 per month, which means
that they are also in $60,000
per year $2 a square foot. And
then we can figure out what
escalations are going to be. But
I just wanted to quickly go, you
know how we do this. And you'll
see why in a minute. It has a
lot of other great ideas for you
know, putting in who pays for
what and operating expenses,
these are things that are very,
very valuable to know where the
different parts of a lease are.
I looked like I left in some of
from a previous use. So you can
see like the suburb
subordination clauses in
paragraph 20, the estoppel
letters and paragraph 21, those
are all where they normally
apply anyway. So there's,
there's our first one, we've got
Joe's store. So let's do one
more quick one. We've already
filled that in. So let's say
this is Bob's restaurant. And so
let's say just for fun that they
started at the same time, and
they're both on five year
leases. So premises is in suite
102. Square footage is let's put
him at 3500 square feet, so
fairly good sized restaurant.
And so if he's starting in
there, we'll put him at six.
And let's put him at ads put him
at a very different dollar
amount. Let's say he starts at
8000 per month. And now we've
got him paying 96,000 per year.
Now this all feeds into our rent
roll, which is also still part
of the NOI and potential value,
right. So we've got this, this
is the the monthly rent. This is
the annual rent, we've got Joe's
store, Bob store, obviously
we've got a 6000 square foot
building. So we've we've now
identified the main parts of our
rent roll for the purposes of
NOI and potential value. Now
this will change as we have
escalations built in, and it'll
have what pass throughs are
really coming in. But let's say
that that are passed through
amount is that we get let's say
it is $1 a square foot, we'll
say it's $12 a square foot and
cams times 5000 I mean times 25.
And then that he is paying $12 a
square foot also. Alright, so
now we have other income as 36.
So now let's look at the NOI
sheet. Now this is the full
sheet that is coming from CCM
and I've just referred to a few
things in here. So what we've
got is how we look at income. So
the way that we start looking at
income is that all that money
that's contracted for is rent
that is contractual, it's likely
to occur. And so we are
basically counting on it. So
that's the potential rent that
you can get in this period.
Right now. Now we also count
vacancies that we think are
going to have going as well. But
you want to make sure to, to
then reduce the amount for
vacancies back out in this
vacancy and credit losses. So
don't make it less than what the
actual dollar amount is, you
want it to be higher. So here
we're using just a rough. So our
total potential rent income is
that 156,000, we are using a 7%
figure, because that came from
here, I came from this
assumption, we change that they
are vacancy and credits risk to
say 5%, because we don't really
have any vacancy. And then
suddenly, now we're using 5%.
That's a much lower figure. So
that leaves us with an effective
rental income. Now here is a big
lever, right? So this is a
lever. Because how we change
that obviously changes this
dollar. Now if I let's, let's
put it back, it's seven.
Okay, so let's put it back at
seven just for fun. And then
we'll see that now. You know,
it's 145 Oh, AD, versus where we
just changed it to swung sheep
to 148 200. So obviously, it's
going to change that amount of
your income and cents and a Why
is your opera is your income
minus your operating expenses.
It's levering the entire
equation, it's changing all
those numbers. And so it's
clearly just delivered to keep
in mind. So let's go ahead and
come up with a few other made
racist. Oops. My clear, oops,
nope, I would rather that. Okay,
got a nice room. All right. So
let's go ahead and finish out
the discussion of, of our noi
calculation. Because the purpose
here is now we've got that first
snapshot that we're talking
about, all we're trying to do is
really get that big, that big
facts, and then little
assumptions, and that this part
right here, that's your little
assumption, that's going to be
changing. So we've now got our
income. Now we need to reduce
our property, our taxes. And so
we can put these in man, by
there. But I've already said
that we've got a that we've got
a large amount of, say we've got
12,000, or we've got $12 A
square foot, times 6000. So
we've already gotten 72,000.
Oops, this didn't add back in,
let me put that in, because this
is our other income amount. So
our other income is the pass
throughs in this in these two
leases, that is there. And then
it also is and I actually would
have would rather put it in, in
so it gets reduced by vacancy
and credit loss. For whatever
reason, cci M didn't do it that
way. The our spreadsheet will
does have it so it reduces that
amount. Because there's really
two types of income, you've got
your pass through income, which
should be counted, and you've
got your other other income
which doesn't. So let's just put
in hard code in that $72,000 of
operating expenses, and now
we've got left with $148,200.
Interestingly, that is the same
amount as our effective gross
rental income.
So let's say we find this
property at a six cap. This is a
property that we actually
already know we think that the
purchase price is going to be
that two to eight oh, so this is
a sorry, a six and a half cap.
So now we've got our purchase
price. And now we've got not all
laid this the noi, but we've
gotten the potential value. Now
this is I'm sure review. But the
main point of why we're going
through it right now is to see
that here is a lever. So this is
what changes everything in
there. Also a lever in here is
this other income, what our
pastures are. Because even
though we've got a, a, an area
in our lease that has these, the
operating expenses and who pays
for what, a lot of times,
probably, I don't know, you've,
you've all seen it 20% of the
time, 25% of the time, you'll
have a landlord who's not really
passing through expenses the way
they can. Some of your bigger
operators definitely will. But
your small time operators tend
to get lazy don't do increases
and don't do pass throughs
really the way they're supposed
to. And so that has a direct
effect on ultimately what though
what you collect, so your income
changes. And then, but we make
assumptions when we're
purchasing the property on
whether or not the landlord's
going to throw a tizzy when we
try and collect those. And they
do and it become it can become a
problem. But it's so it's an
assumption that you're making,
that ultimately is a lever on
the whole thing. So under the
CCM sheets, we have proposed it
under this. So let's say we'll
just leave that like that. Now,
they also use different measures
for here. So let's say our so
we'll talk a little bit about
cash flow, because here, we're
at a new a whole new level.
Alright, so this is the third
step. And this is the cash flow
step. So now we're at the third
step of the four step analysis.
I think it's a little bit
confusing the way that that CCM
is decided to build it out just
for other people. And for really
kind of seeing where those where
those levers are. Whoops, back.
So let's put in the first huge
lever that we come to here is we
are looking at the amount of our
loan. So let's say we lever it
at 65% loan, just 140 or
11482000. Say our interest rate
is 4%. Our amortization period
is 25 years. Our loan term is it
doesn't really matter for this
purpose. But we'll just say it's
10. And our payments per year is
12. So that's all normal. Now
we've got our normal debt
service built into here. And so
now and hope we have a good
positive cash flow. Okay, good
we do. So now we've got a nice
positive cash flow.
We've got a nice positive cash
flow. Now we've got built into
our cash flow, we've still got
these levers. And there isn't a
considerable amount of work to
do in there in the way they
underwrite the sheet. But let's
look at the levers specifically.
So we've got we've got the debt
portion, right? I mean, here's a
big lever. So how we're going to
be doing debt is a big, big
lever. And that becomes a whole
different topic of conversation.
So we'll talk about that more
next week, about about debt and
how that works on here. Because
ultimately, it's such a big
lever and it's it will change
everything about how you how
your underwriting goes to buy
that property and to really fund
it with syndication. It becomes
it becomes very critical. Not
that there's others. So and
everything comes forward. Right.
So, like we talked about before,
we've got our net operating
income is a major lever. So that
changes and then everything else
changes in the cash flow. And so
part of one of those levers to
was somehow I lost my thing is
what are, this was a lever that
we had from noi, as was vacancy
and credit loss. So those are
levers, now we've got our
interest is our lever, we're not
going to go through
participation payments or cost
recovery. It's just it's not
important for what we're doing.
And so our amortization are the
other things our leasing
Commission's right, if you're
going to need to lease the
property out, that's a below the
line cost that's going to be
affecting you. We also have our
capital expenses now here, up
up, up up up above ups, because
we are we're still in the
textbook calculation. Oops, and
then that throws everything off
that I've just learned. Alright.
So we have our leasing
Commission's is one, our funded
reserves is one, remember, we
talked about that? We've got our
I would have put capital
expenses here as as an actual
thing. So let's just change this
that's a lever, there's a lot of
levers that go into into this
part into the cash flow
statement. And each of them
changes everything that we're
doing in terms of where we get.
All right. Does that make sense?
Are you getting the topic of
levers? Give me a nice Yes. Or
no? Alonzo Christian, yes. Yes.
Okay, good. So ultimately, then
that leads us to, to the topic
of our sales. And for those who
came in late, the reason that
we're going through this, we'll
go back over it again, in the
beginning, just to finish up.
But we're going through the
fourth step financial analysis,
the last step is the performance
step. And this is what your
investors actually care about.
More than anything else. So
we've got our our cash flows,
what it would look like what a
potential sale looks like.
Nothing, nothing new or
extremely interesting. Again,
taxes isn't really relevant to
what the conversation of
syndication, it will be part, it
is part of your your sheets as
well, just because it should be.
And just so that you have that
information. And so you can use
it on just investment property
sales, or you could do it, you
use it, so you can use it in
brokerage, or you can use it in
syndication. And now here,
you've got ultimately your IRR,
returns. So you sell it at your
nice middle, your before tax is
a 15% return, which is pretty
good. So for this sample
property, we've got a nice
reasonable return for our
investors over a five year hold
period. Now, again, we have
levers in here. So all of those
things that that took place here
in cash flow in the here, but
but so are our debt, because
this was part of cash flow is a
lever, right, we change that it
automatically is a major level,
our sales price is a lever. And
a lot of these I mean, you you
don't know what it's going to
sell for in five years. But we
have to make assumptions. So
this is one of the bigger
assumptions that we have to
make. So it should be a
reasonable assumption and
supported by evidence. But then
we have our cost of our cost of
sale. And this is your broker
fees, right. So this is the
amount of money that you maybe
are taking as a brokerage
commission for half of the deal.
So in this simple transaction,
you're making, you know, over
$80,000 in a for the sale of the
property. I say 80 because
that's half of 165 Splitting out
both you it's a very bad idea to
double end a deal when you are
acting as the seller. So that's
why it's half of that. So and
then ultimately we've got you
know, the whole period is five
years. And so we have a a nice
reasonable return as our result.
And all of it was affected by
all of those levers. So let me
switch back to, to what we where
we started.
So all of these levers are now
have all added up to giving us,
you know, a, an IRR of 15%. But
if you change any one of these
things, you're suddenly going to
have a change in that 15%. I
mean, not really the potential
value this is there more for
more for brokerage than for then
specifically for what we're
underwriting for here, but
nevertheless. So, but if we had
changed the vacancy credit risk,
our IRR would change, we make
the credit risk or vacancy
percentage we're using much
higher, we're suddenly going to
have that that 15.0 to fall down
below 40, below 15. If you
change the how you are going to
be getting that your pass
throughs recovered, that's going
to also if you think Well, I'm
not going to be able to recover
at all, then you're going to
need to drop that down. You're
in your cash flow, if you decide
to do an asset management fee,
which these sheets don't use,
that's going to reduce the
amount. If you decide, okay, I
need to put more to reserves,
that's going to reduce the
amount. So all of those things
change, ultimately, this return
that your investor is looking
for. So when you come to the end
of end of your analysis, what
you want to have is to have a
nice sheet that's well supported
by by a really well done
financial analysis that says,
Okay, this is what we're
projecting. And this is why and
you've balanced out to optimize
it as much as possible. You've
tweaked the amount of asset
management versus property
management, versus how much debt
we're gonna take versus all
those things to hit that target.
There's 15% That you are
striving for. So that 15% is, is
the goal, because you've already
identified through your fit that
the risk tolerance level for
your investors is 15%. Now
actually, I made up the numbers
completely as we were going, and
it just worked out perfectly to
be 15%. So that was great. But
that was purely by accident. It
was I know, I know, I definitely
deserve a lot of kudos for that.
I hope you found the four step
financial analysis process to be
useful to you. Feel free to give
me a call if you need help
setting up real estate
syndication or real estate fund
where you're looking to raise
money for your business or
you're looking to you're a
developer and you need
additional capital. We're the
people that call when you're
doing a Regulation D Rule 506b
or 506c offering